Posted 2-19-13
Thank you to everyone who completed the parent survey and shared thoughts or suggestions on a plan being considered to adjust attendance zones for Bear Creek Elementary and Grapevine Elementary to alleviate crowding at BCES.
Based on your feedback and another review of the demographic projections, the proposal has been revised slightly. The new plan permanently rezones a smaller area, now bordered by Baze Road to the west, Kathleen Lane to the east, Glade Road to the north and Augustine Drive to the south. The plan also allows for up to 20 voluntary transfers from BCES families.
We understand that adjusting attendance zones is difficult and it is not the preference of district leaders to move students, as we understand the value of friendships and family connections to each of our schools. However, in situations of significant overcrowding, adjusting attendance zones often is the most feasible and realistic option for both short- and long-term relief. In the case of BCES, student enrollment has been at capacity for several years already. While demographic projections show that the school’s enrollment will begin to decrease next year and over the next two to three years due to outgoing larger grade levels, it is not enough to achieve the district’s goal to lower BCES’ enrollment to approximately 700 students.
The following information is provided in response to questions or comments from parents on this matter. Listed below are the most frequently asked questions. Topics are listed in random order.
What is the plan for attendance zone adjustment?
Under the revised plan being proposed, approximately 43 students who currently attend BCES would attend GES beginning with the 2013-2014 school year. BCES students who will be in the fifth grade next year may choose to stay at BCES for the year, and their siblings also could remain for the year. After next year, those siblings would move to GES beginning with the 2014-2015 school year, bringing the total number of BCES students who will move to GES from the rezoned area over the next two years to approximately 56. Additionally, the district will allow up to 20 more students to voluntarily transfer to GES as an additional measure until BCES’ larger grade levels move to middle school. The proposed plan includes a combination of two options:
- Permanently re-zone a designated area from BCES to GES. The area being considered is bordered by Baze Road to the west, Kathleen Lane to the east, Glade Road to the north and Augustine Drive to the south.
- Voluntary transfers from BCES families to GES for up to 20 students.
How were the attendance zone lines determined?
Many factors and data have been considered when determining where to adjust the attendance zones. These include the number of students in each geographical area, campus enrollment trends and projections, proximity to GES, building capacities, possible staffing adjustments, the impact on families in these school communities, and parent feedback. With assistance from the district demographer, campus principals and district administrators evaluated all these factors in drafting new attendance zone lines that transfer students from BCES to GES to relieve overcrowding at BCES while also managing student enrollment at GES.
Will this impact middle school and/or high school attendance?
No. All students attending either Bear Creek or Grapevine Elementary are zoned to attend Heritage Middle School and Colleyville Heritage High School and that would not change under the proposed plan. Additionally, no plans have been discussed to adjust attendance zones at the middle or high school level.
What other attendance zone adjustments are being planned in the district?
While district leaders continually monitor enrollment and school capacities, no other attendance zone adjustments are being planned for the coming year.
How will this impact class sizes?
The state prefers a ratio of 22 students per teacher in grades K-4. No guidance exists for grade 5. The student-teacher ratios at BCES and GES currently are about the same, with about 20 students per teacher on average. District and campus leaders have reviewed the proposed plan and do not anticipate that it will have much impact on current class sizes. It is possible that current class sizes at both schools could decrease slightly under the proposed plan. One way the district will be managing class sizes is through the voluntary transfer process, which allows us to regulate enrollment into classes with capacity. However, class sizes are impacted more by budget limitations than student enrollment. Smaller class sizes means more classes, which means more teachers are needed. In 2011, the Texas Legislature cut state funding for public education by $5.4 billion, which equated to $14 million for GCISD. With the loss to state funding, coupled with limitations of the existing state school finance system, GCISD and school districts across the state will not have the resources available to continue to maintain class sizes below the state ratios.
What are the enrollment projections for BCES and what if it becomes overcrowded again?
With the exception of 2011-2012 when BCES experienced a temporary decrease in students, BCES has seen steady, substantial growth for the past five years. For the current school year, BCES has added 21 students since the first day of school. However, enrollment is projected to begin declining at BCES and then level out in about five years due to outgoing larger grade levels. District leaders will continue to monitor enrollment.
How will this impact Grapevine Elementary’s student enrollment?
Under the proposed plan, GES attendance is projected to increase by 56 students from the rezoned area over the next two years. In addition, up to 20 students would be added through voluntary transfers. GES’ enrollment is projected to increase slightly over the next five years due to new residential developments being constructed. However, GES also has larger outgoing grade levels that will balance the addition of students from the rezoned area and transfers. GES currently has available classrooms for additional classes.
Are the new apartments being built behind Super Target on Glade Road going to be part of the GCISD tax base? Where will students from the new apartments behind Super Target be zoned to attend school?
The apartments named Station 2800 at Glade Parks are part of GCISD and are zoned under the current and the proposed attendance zones to attend Heritage Elementary, Colleyville Middle and Colleyville Heritage High School.
What is the number of students classified as economically disadvantaged for each school and what is the projection with the adjustment to attendance zones?
The number of economically disadvantaged students in the proposed zone is less than 10 and will have no significant impact on GES.
| BCES | GES |
| Current | 183 | 42 |
| Projected | 174 | 51 |
| Difference | -9 | +9 |
Didn’t the bond construction at BCES this summer eliminate the overcrowding at that campus?
Not entirely. While the addition at BCES from the 2011 Bond Program did provide much-needed classroom space, the district was not able to address the available space and functionality of common areas such as the cafeteria, gym, music room, hallways, etc., that remain overcrowded with current enrollment. The bond program added four traditional classrooms, two partitioned classrooms and additional restrooms between the third- and fourth-grade halls. Student projections made in 2009-2010 showed the current “enrollment bubble” of large class sizes at BCES and also showed BCES’ enrollment would begin to decrease when smaller grades replace the larger grades. For example, the current kindergarten at BCES has 113 and first grade has 126 while fourth and fifth grades have 145 and 131 respectively. This alone can reduce BCES’ enrollment by 37 students. The Bond Planning Committee believed that the best financial course of action was to address classrooms and restrooms and otherwise wait on the enrollment “bubble” to move through the campus.
Why was money spent on building new classrooms at BCES when they are still overcrowded? Did the district consider building a new school to accommodate overcrowding at BCES?
The Bond Planning Committee (which included parents, citizens and staff members) reviewed demographic data and costs of buying land and building a new school. Based on a predicted loss of enrollment at BCES and GES and all other schools in GCISD, the BPC determined that it was not feasible or necessary to build another elementary school to handle a temporary enrollment bubble. GES was projected to have capacity. Therefore, the BPC opted to add classrooms to BCES to handle core instruction. This also allowed students to continue attending a neighborhood school that was less than two miles from their home.
If I voluntarily change schools, will my address be permanently re-zoned?
No, your home would not be permanently re-zoned. The voluntary transfer applies only to you while you live at the address listed. Only homes in the proposed area to be moved will be permanently re-zoned to GES. BCES families who are accepted for the voluntary transfer to GES will remain at GES until they move to the middle school or move from the home.
If my older student transfers to GES, would my younger children also go to GES?
The district will make every effort to keep families together at the same school.
Do both schools offer the same programs?
In most cases. In addition to the standard academic programs, all GCISD elementary schools offer a “specials” rotation that provides a full year of physical education and music as well as a nine-week rotation of art and Spanish. Below is a comparison of additional programs and extra-curricular activities offered at BCES and GES.
| | BCES | GES |
Breakfast Club | 
|
|
| Choir |  |  |
| Destination Imagination |  |  |
| Digital Classrooms |  |  |
| Field Day |  |  |
| Geography Bee |  | |
| Homework Club |  | |
| Instrument Ensemble | |  |
| KC Club (Kindness and Compassion) |  |  |
| KidzU before/after-school care program |  |  |
| Marimba Band |  | |
| Morning video announcements |  |  |
| Outdoor classroom |  |  |
| Orchestra |  | |
| PAT program |  |  |
| Running club |  |  |
| Spelling Bee |  |  |
| Star Bank | |  |
| Student Council |  |  |
| Volunteer Safety Patrol |  |  |
If a child needs tutoring or support services, will they still get it at GES?
Yes. Specialized services for students, such as Speech and Dyslexia, are provided to all students in GCISD based on an identified, individual student need. If a student at BCES receives specialized services, the same services will continue at GES and GES staff will work closely with BCES staff to ensure a seamless transition. At GES, student academic interventions are offered during the instructional day as part of “Shine Time” and Reading Recovery. Additionally, before- and after-school tutorials may be offered to support students in meeting academic goals.
Can we visit GES before deciding if we want to apply for a voluntary transfer?
Families considering voluntary transfer may contact GES Principal Kim Blackburn individually about touring Grapevine Elementary. Ms. Blackburn will make every effort to accommodate requests as she is able, but may not be able to accommodate large groups or immediate requests. GES currently is not planning a formal meeting for BCES parents considering this option. Such a meeting would be held after the Board of Trustees approves the attendance zone adjustment.
Can we choose another elementary school besides GES for voluntary transfer?
The district’s intra-district transfer policy, FDB(LOCAL), allows parents to submit applications annually for transfer to any school where there is capacity for additional students. Transfers must meet certain criteria to be approved. Heritage Elementary, the next closest elementary school to BCES besides GES, does not have capacity to accept transfers at this time. However, O.C. Taylor Elementary School currently has capacity to accept additional students.
How do I apply for a transfer to GES?
If the Board of Trustees approves a recommendation that includes voluntary transfers, information about the process for applying, the timeline and the application forms would be available online and at BCES by March 1.
If I transfer to GES and don’t like it, can I return to BCES?
Yes. District policy allows transfer students to return to their home campus at the end of the semester.
What is the process for finalizing a decision and how will parents be informed of the decision?Your district leaders and campus Principals have conducted a thorough review and consideration of the responses submitted through the parent survey, as well as individual questions/comments we have received from parents. Based on this feedback, a review of demographic projections and the need to alleviate crowding at BCES, a recommendation for an attendance zone adjustment will be presented to the Board of Trustees for action on February 25. This recommendation will be posted on the Board’s agenda at least 72 hours prior to the meeting, which will be before 7 p.m. on Friday, February 22. Parents also are receiving information from their Principal regarding the plan being recommended to the Board. If the Board approves the plan, the district will post a news release on the district website and both school websites, and parents in the area to be re-zoned also will receive an invitation to a welcome event at GES.
Will BCES parents have visibility of the recommendation prior to it being presented to the Board?Yes. The recommendation will be posted on the Board’s agenda at least 72 hours prior to the meeting. Parents also are receiving information from their Principal regarding the plan being recommended to the Board. Anyone wishing to speak at a Board meeting should visit the Frequently Asked Questions link on the
Board of Trustees webpage for details about Open Forum procedures.